IAS in Kashmir: Glorifying Occupation

IAS in Kashmir: Glorifying Occupation
  • 143
By Rouf Dar, Umar Lateef Misgar, Harun Lone
Once a child is born from the womb of a Kashmiri mother, he becomes anti-Indian by default. While growing up, family alignments, social compulsions or economic constraints may influence his political behaviour but the sentiment of resistance always exists. A child born amidst conflict is never a normal child. At every stage of life his choices are vastly determined by the conflict. Sometimes he may ignore his basic existence and collaborate with the occupier. If Kashmir was to be a sovereign state, both internally and externally, nobody would disagree that most Kashmiri youths resisting Indian occupation, and staying away from the latter’s machinery, would have joined civil services as a career option. And it isn’t just the fact that the conflict shapes this alienation from bureaucracy, but it is a morally and politically empirical process too.
A Colonial Legacy
During British imperial rule in India, the civil service was introduced during the reign of Lord Cornwallis.  Initially, only white people were eligible. But in 1855, the term “Indian Civil Service” made an entry into the colonial lexicon of British India and it was in 1863 that Satyandernath Tagore became the first native to qualify ICS. The number of Indians who joined ICS increased gradually and Britishers were able to create a class of civil servants who were born Indians but served foreign interests in their own land.
Unlike the class of freedom fighters who were educated in foreign lands and resisted British rule, this class of British-ified bureaucrats worked exactly in the opposite manner. It was through this class that the British strengthened their stranglehold on the Indian subcontinent. A fact that was acknowledged by the British PM David Lloyd George himself who, while speaking in the House of Commons in 1935, said that ICS was “the steel frame on which the whole structure of government in India rests”. These civil servants were always embroiled in a tussle with Indian freedom fighters who viewed the former as an important apparatus of the British. This prompted Jawaharlal Nehru to historically remark that the ICS was “neither Indian, nor civil, nor service”. Subash Chandra Bose, India’s Netaji, stood fourth in the ICS batch of 1920. He reported for training but resigned in 1921 and later established the Indian National Army, becoming a legendary freedom fighter.
When India finally managed to liberate itself from British imperialism, the ICS remained as such albeit with a change in nomenclature. It became the Indian Administrative Service. The same exists till date and has been extended to Kashmir.
Theoretical Perspective
Bureaucracy finds its origin in the French word “bureau” which means desk. Thus, bureaucracy implies a system of administration which operates from the desk or table. To break it down further, bureaucracy refers to governance through bureaucrats. Max Weber, the 20th century sociologist, described bureaucracy as a system of administration characterised by expertness, impartiality and absence of humanity. He propounded that bureaucracy is an administrative system designed to accomplish large-scale administrative tasks by systematically coordinating the work of many individuals. ‘Bureaucrats’ in the subcontinent is also used interchangeably with the word ‘civil servants’, which literally means servants of the public; though the Indian media has devised a new name for this class viz; “babus”, and the system, “babudom”.
As Weber pointed out, it is actually these civil servants who run the daily affairs of government in a country and exercise the power of elected representatives in real terms. Though members of the executive are elected through an election the functions of the executive are essentially translated onto the ground by these civil servants. It is here that civil servants become an instrument of unbridled power. The transfer of real power from elected representatives to bureaucrats is a brazen violation of substantive democratisation principles and a process not consented to, de facto, by the people.
That Sardar Patel would go on to recognise the ‘valiant efforts’ of these civil servants in uniting India gives us a picture of how vital a position they occupied within the power hierarchy of independent India. Patel even anticipated a collapse of the country had this class not existed. Thus, after independence, the power organisation remained intact, just the nomenclature changed. That’s exactly true in Kashmir where India laid down the same base and cultivated an exemplified collaborative class.
Marx becomes relevant here too. He thought of a ‘proletariat revolution’ against capitalism but not of a ‘student rebellion’ against it, as students also are exploited like workers, but students aren’t directly as exploited as workers. In that case, IAS is a bigger monster and other jobs are lesser evils. IAS is neither a class nor a stratum. It is an upshot of the dissection of society into classes (which state uses) and class struggles (which ordinary people do), since its utility is to safeguard the recognition of the rules of an order (an order undoubtedly connected with relations of production, but in need of being prepared in comprehensive terms and maintained by force). So, IAS is “normally” at the service of a dominant class.
How Our Society Sees Them
Coming to Kashmir, these local henchmen of Indian occupation play a more pervasive role in helping to consolidate the illegal rule of India over the insurgent nation. This new breed – Faesal’ians et al – proudly proclaim to be “Indians”. And the tragedy of our nation is that they are positioned at the topmost level of the “respect spectrum.” Parents fight to turn them into “in-laws”. Students get lured into the glitter of this mercenary cosmos. But glitter is all it is. One wash, and the blood begins to seep. Innocent blood, of slain humans. Tears of waiting mothers. Broken limbs and lives of tortured women and men. Screams of raped men and women.
This section of Kashmiri society, and they are many by now., who find no wrong in Kashmiris opting for civil services, argue that a corruption-free society has to be realised and for that we need honest bureaucrats at the helm. What they undermine is that corruption is integral to every society and to think that an independent Kashmir will have zero corruption is a gross misunderstanding. With the demand for independence and resistance against occupation, we are not yearning for a Platonic ideal state. Rather we are demanding a resolution to the longstanding conflict after which any alien entity has no say whatsoever in our political, social or economic affairs.
Some others argue that the lack of sufficient employment opportunities in Kashmir is responsible for pushing youth towards civil services. If, for the sake of argument, we accept that, there arises a visible contradiction in the existing scenario. And that is statistics suggesting that most of the qualifiers are employees of some department or the other before they go for civil services. What prompts them to become civil servants? Preferably to be a well-versed member in the power hierarchy put in place by India in Kashmir. Some of the qualifiers sit for further chances, even after qualifying the exam, just to enhance their ranks! A competition of enhancing prestige among loyal collaborative ranks exists here. And an uninhibited desire to gain power which consolidates foreign strangulation of the Valley.
Who They Really Are
We are appalled at the pathos that drives some people of our nation to embark upon a life of white-washing crimes against humanity and polishing (if our respectful shoe polishers don’t find this insulting) a regime that has turned Kashmir into the world’s most militarised space. An Indian trooper kills; an IAS guy lays a road over corpses. A school child is shot; a KAS chap builds couple of bathrooms. Maybe that’s what their “services” are worth.
Nobody is immune in a conflict zone. Bullets of the occupier never discriminate. The civil servants gain this collaborative power to build layers of security around themselves. They know, in times of duress, they can tap in some offices or dial a few numbers and go into hiding. This is a false sense of holding power. Their dear ones, or society, will respect them not because they have traversed a difficult path but just because acquaintance with them shall ensure some safety perks. This respect and demigod-making is fear-driven.
Civil services is like cotton candy. One can call it “Afsoos Mithaai”’ a ruse India is baffling these aspirants with. To go further, they are quite the same as SOG personnel or “Nawbids”. They are Malcolm X’s “House Negroes”. With them, India succeeds in pitting Kashmiris against their own people. The SOG crop attains ranks because of their prior actions. The IAS crop executes actions because of their prior qualifications. They dance to the tunes of politicians who may not possess even a matric certificate. The ink from their fountain pens write ‘PSA’ on a minor boy’s life. And the most important duty they have is to perpetuate the occupation.
On a meritorious scale, how do they rank higher? How can a year, or many, of machine-like preparations prove the worth of a person? How can memorising facts and information like a computer entitle them to be ‘great’? They have no merit because they have no moral position that is sustainable. Their ideas change with the lust in their bellies. They see the world in terms of power and money, not in terms of real people.
How They Defend Themselves
The common defense mechanism of the collaborator class to deflect critiques is that “They won’t be irrational” and “They want a roadmap, a clear plan for Azadi”. This mercenary logic, in its deconstructed form, is not only hypocrisy but also alarming due to the fact that they see themselves as working in the administration of a free Kashmiri nation. The confidence is also reflective of the comfort and acceptance they enjoy in social spheres. On the other hand, people who bravely fight the loathsome structures of Indian domination, from stone-pelters to militants, often find themselves ostracised and relegated to being social outcasts.
Then there is the logic of “changing the system from inside”. A struggle against a colonial system, throughout history, has almost always been motivated by the idea of national liberation. In other words, complete decimation of the colonial structure. Any attempts to modify the colonial structure are only cosmetic at best and deceptive at worst. It’s like trying to make destructive capitalism more tolerable to prevent large-scale workers’ movements. Colonialists and capitalists both try to band-aid the death and devastation they bring, in which co-opters come handy and cheap. Also, in 69 years of Kashmir’s military occupation, no ‘insider’ has ever dared to either rebel or change the system once they are within. Not to say that we expect any justice from this organically unjust system, but how many cases of human rights violations were properly investigated, let alone prosecuted, in post Faesalian (read Faustian) time? Was there any attempt to address the political aspirations of Kashmiris? Or is there even any acknowledgement of such aspirations ?
The third, and possibly the most ridiculous counter-critique of state collaborators is that their only job is to “sign papers”, “prepare budgets”, “manage the workforce” or “dole out orders”. Only that the signature may approve a PSA detention, a budget might be used to purchase weaponry and the workforce could be a lethal group of child murderers. Also, not pulling the trigger doesn’t morally or legally (under international law, especially the Rome Statute) absolve one of all responsibility. In fact, the sheer coldness of “administering murder” behind a desk can be more atrocious. Not to undermine the insurmountable tragedy of the Holocaust, Adolf Eichmann also “just managed logistics” for the Nazis.
Why Should We Emulate Them?
What is happening at the family level is pathetic as well. Parents have accepted the IAS’ self-image, which is actually false. The ‘IAS pull’ on our parents is stronger than ever. Parents have made their children a commodity weighed in terms of the intimidating power and money that IAS can buy. How can they, who have fallen under its incantation, discharge themselves from this bewitchment?
Parents need to understand that love for such malignant power without any moral conscience and love for a revolutionary life which needs a fair degree of hardship cannot go together. Their love ultimately becomes a decisive force to put children into this ethical gutter. Countless numbers in our community have wasted precious years with the obsession of qualifying this exam.Desmond Tutu famously said that “If in the times of injustice you stand neutral, you are on the side of the oppressor”. Parents become a party to that in Kashmir. Not only do they stand by the side of IAS characters but become an active force of oppression as well. Parents bring their wrath on children when some of them oppose the idea of IAS. They own qualifiers and disown us. They forcibly make children believe that an ‘IAS life’ brings power, reputation, bungalows, cars, and a peaceful life.
This Vichy-like regime of cold-blooded mercenaries has to be dealt not only with rejection, confrontation and critical engagement but also with ridicule. Our society, introspectively, needs to dethrone the false crowns placed on the heads of such people. We need to stop carving heroes out of them. We, by no means, should try to emulate them and lose our prime to this collaborative obsession. We need to get rid of the respect that stems out of fear.
We have to uncover their true faces and reveal the colonial structures that they help to build and operate in Kashmir so that, in some semblance of conscientious conduct, they refrain or, even better, start a total rebellion (mass resignation) and, to be more hopeful and just, post-liberation, face a Kashmiri version of Nuremberg.
But for now, let us not differentiate between occupiers and collaborators. The gun of a soldier on the road is controlled by a bureaucrat using a table in a government office.
—The writers are students at KU and IUST

35 Responses to "IAS in Kashmir: Glorifying Occupation"

  1. Indian army jindabaad   June 4, 2018 at 10:02 pm

    Kashmiri idea of freedom is based on religious ground, hence it will never be successful.
    A better option for Kashmiris is to engage with Indian state, moderate their religious veiws and keep giving details of terrorists to Indian Army, or else enjoy pellet guns.

  2. Khan   April 1, 2018 at 11:51 pm

    I dont know who you are but I just want to thank you, because I think you have done your job as a part of Kashmir.
    I have the option to go for IAS but then i ask myself, when on the day of judgement, ALLAH will ask me, “So, which side you had been in Kashmir”? What will b my answer to His Majesty!!!
    Civil Services, strengthens the root of Illegal Indian occupation of Kashmir and if it had not been so, then whole India would have cried instead, when Shah Faisal topped the exam and hence forthwith others do as well. But as we all see, everytime we produce IAS qualifiers, whole Centre at Delhi praises them and invites Kashmiri(especially) guys to PM office because it just eases their way to slap PSA’s on innocent children, to kill young generation, to built army camps etc etc
    Consience is everything, if u dont have it then u r not alive!

  3. Sultan Mahmood   February 28, 2018 at 9:09 pm

    Your the one with 5000 year old sick ancestors” you cow piss drinkers, pacifists”

  4. Sultan Mahmood   February 28, 2018 at 8:56 pm

    UN 2014 report” that 7000 men women and children are dying of *Hungar* every day” and their corpses are being eaten by dogs and cats in streets all over india. no one asleep hungry in Pakistan. You have 5000 year old sick ancestry.

  5. Sultan Mahmood   February 28, 2018 at 8:49 pm

    Get out of Kashmir before Kashmir breaks India.

  6. Rana   February 28, 2018 at 1:25 pm

    The only surprising thing on this newspaper is the fact that almost every article and column has only one agenda i.e. hatred towards anything and everything that is India and Indian. Some serious
    hate filled rhetoric. But if this is what the youth of Kashmir have to offer to their society then its not only sad but unfortunate.
    Almost every rant is about Azadi. I have a question. What will you do with freedom? Do you even understand it ? To respect freedom we must learn to value life.
    Freedom is worthless without human values.What I see here is intolerance and a sustained campaign of hatred directed towards a perceived enemy.
    The ability to read and write has come to you from the schools and colleges run by your perceived enemy.
    The ability to think and criticise was born in the safety of your drawing rooms and bed rooms which is maintained by your parents who in turn are provided the ability to do so by the same state machinery that you vociferously condemn.
    The body that sustains you draws its nutrition from the food that is produced and harvested in the same enemy country that you hate.
    Now a person who lives and breathes under the blanket of security provided by the very state that it relentlessly condemns is best defined as an ingrate traitor to the collective conscience of this nation.
    By your words I am certain that till date you have made no contributions to your society whether great or small in any conspicuous manner. The easiest occupation in the world is that of a critic
    because he does little apart from exercising his fingers and jowls and I am sure that Srinagar is no short of such examples just like the rest of India.
    And I am also certain about the future of Kashmir if it is upto the trio. A nation steeped in violence and brute dogmatism and intolerance reminiscent of the dark ages. A Kashmir that will relive the legacy of Sikandar Butshikan and espouse the extremities of the the FATA regions of our great neighbour Pakistan.

  7. Rocky   February 19, 2018 at 3:15 pm

    I think the kashmir problem is a problem just like any other state of country,Our country is the best place to live in case you do not want to follow any law and can do anything as per your will.The air of freedom which we breathe in, which is fresh full of enjoyment.
    We must realise one thing that INDIA is a super power in making either you join it or not would not make any difference as in population of 125 Cr kashmir is just a drop of water.
    So best is to enjoy the ocean because this ocean gallops all the water which comes in.

  8. Piyush   February 19, 2018 at 11:49 am

    Long Live India, long Live Kashmir, Long Live you brother Ahmad

  9. Piyush   February 19, 2018 at 11:48 am

    No God gives food without an effort

    Go & beg in Pakistan

  10. Vipin Chandra   February 8, 2018 at 2:42 pm

    To the pro-Azadi Brigade – you have a choice – you can keep on provoking the security forces with your stone pelting and ambushes and what not. It will only provoke more violence and not less.

    The other choice is to exercise your own democratic right as a state of India. Elect your own representatives and let them run the state to your liking.

    If you choose to align with Pakistan, not exactly a paragon of virtues in the comity of nations, then let me tell this to you. No one in the civilized world wants another Pakistan. India does not want a Jihadi state next door.

    This is the reality. You can choose to ignore it at your peril

  11. SkB_Australia   January 28, 2017 at 4:33 am

    Bilal Bhat people who choose to close eye from reality & lives in fools paradise disappear in history…
    Red Indians in America
    Inuites in Canada
    Aborigines in Australia
    Buddhist in Tibet
    Where freeeom of these people have gone!!!!!!

  12. SkB_Australia   January 28, 2017 at 4:25 am

    You pittiful losers!!!
    You can ignite passions in innocent Kashmiri youth
    But no iota of truth in your argument!!!
    You are living in a house where your father is paying your bills & you are accusing him to give all the liberties of world but no responsibility!!!
    You scumbags- Kashmir is a land locked geography, even if you get freedom how you are going to run s country when you have nothing on one side there is a powerful jihadi army other side it will be same india you hate.
    If you think NAPAKistan will help you because you are Muslim brother
    Come out of fools paradise & check with Mohajirs in Karachi … they are crying with bloody tears to come back to india.

  13. BILAL BHAT   August 23, 2016 at 12:58 pm

    The selection of a few more Kashmiris in the Indian Administrative Services (IAS) for the consecutive eighth year has triggered a debate in Kashmir. It is about whether Kashmiris, who are stuck in an interminable conflict since the past 60 years, should join or celebrate the Indian “civil services” or not?
    The side that supports the celebration puts forward the point that it will strengthen Kashmiris in the bureaucracy which would dramatically turn the equation of power on their side. By having greater say, they would influence policies and plans. The opposite view is that by entering the Indian bureaucracy, Kashmiris would end up as “mini-screwdrivers” who would only perpetuate violence against their own people. By acting as tools of the Indian power structure, these “civil servants” would strengthen India in Kashmir.
    The debate whether to join the IAS or not was triggered largely after an article titled “IAS in Kashmir: Glorifying the occupation” was published in the daily newspaper Kashmir Reader. The article took the social media by storm where people expressed their views about the “civil services”.
    As the debate was on, another write-up appeared in The Indian Express titled “Till Azadi comes”. The essay was written by the IAS poster boy in Kashmir, Dr Shah Faesal, who had topped civil services exam in 2009. It came as a shock to me. The article was primarily arguing that Kashmiris should go for a political compromise as Azadi was a far-fetched dream. It suggested that there is hopelessness as far as Azadi is concerned and hence it will be better for Kashmiris to surrender and join the Indian mainstream.
    How can people join the state which has been shedding their blood and heaping on them indignity? The state that led an all-out war against Kashmiris by blasting their houses, killing men and women, subjecting thousands of people to enforced disappearances, and inflicting countless miseries upon Kashmirs. How can one describe the crimes of genocidal nature on part of the Indian state as just “disturbance”? By doing so, you are not only trivialising the struggle, but also taking sides with the occupier.
    Doctors and Engineers have rendered countless sacrifices for the Kashmir cause. Their resolve to gain freedom has led them to resist oppression at every step. At times it has cost them their lives. Turn back the pages of history and see how many “civil servants” have raised their voice against the oppression by the state. If being an IAS officer means resistance, Dr Shah Faesal, why didn’t you write against the oppression of the Handwara girl? What was her crime? Wasn’t it your moral obligation to speak up for her when she was going through trauma? We have enough of resources and talent to deal with unemployment, if we are allowed to utilise them. A few IAS seats are not a solution to unemployment. Even if India gives us 100% of the civil services seats, it will fall short of 1% of our educated youth.
    Between 1990 and 2008, ten times more youth were employed by the Gulf countries then by the Government of India. When it comes to choice of one’s career, compromises should not be made, and ethics, principles and bonds with one’s fellow people should never be cast away. The choice of a civil services career is a personal one and should not be played up as an alternative to the political aspirations of the citizens of Jammu and Kashmir.
    The upward mobility of a few families of civil servants hardly helps the poor on the streets or the half-widows longing for their husbands. No one in Kashmir opposes students getting admissions in IITs, IIMs, and excelling in cricket, but the civil services, the armed forces, and the police are state machinery that supervises in Kashmir mass murders, rapes, abductions, torture, and much else. Let us learn to call a spade a spade. No cause is more critical than the Kashmiri struggle for dignity. Every family in Kashmir has suffered, whether rich or poor. IAS aspirants can never be called Kashmiri heroes as they are bound by the Indian state and India and Kashmir are like parallel lines that will never meet. There is no confusion in history as to where India ends and Kashmir begins. So does everyone in Kashmir and in India.
    Everyone has his own battles to fight but no battle is bigger than the collective one. The Kashmiri struggle is definitely about politics, war, traditions and culture. It is about a dignified life in which your children are not killed, mothers and sisters are not molested, heritage and demography are not changed. It is about eradicating corruption and inequality. It is about telling the truth in whole and not in parts. It is about allowing people to nurture their apple orchards, to be upright and active for their rights and against oppression. The IAS gives us none of these, and so it is nothing to celebrate in Kashmir.
    Rebellion or militancy is not a career; it is a passion, an ultimate sacrifice, which is far above a worldly career. It is the ultimate commitment to the nation when a human opts for death so that his fellows can live. These martyrs never die, they live in our hearts till eternity. We don’t need memorials to them because they live in our breath. No one has ever stopped living in Kashmir, not the mother who lost her four sons in the fight against Indian occupation, nor the people in the village where every woman was raped in a single night. The only difference is that what they call life is not what you and I call life.
    The dawn of Azadi is bound to come. I leave you with just one question: Will you be left with enough spirit to dance on the day?

  14. Rahul   August 21, 2016 at 1:59 am

    Wow. This is the first time I’ve visited this website and the quality of arguments and write ups here are truly marvelous. Happened to chance upon it when a concerned friend shared an article about inhuman treatment of a youth by the army.

    I tend to ignore these “mishap shares” on social media mostly. The beating of a lower caste man brutally by a policeman, a Hindu dragging a Muslim behind his jeep, the maiming of Hindu kids by Muslim bombers, the rapes of women in the name of religion or caste or just simply driven by lust.

    These unfortunate incidents fill my mind with negativity – something none of us crave for. Thus, I ignore, resultantly living happier than I would if I filled my mind with them.

    Anyhow, for some reason intrigued by what’s been going wrong in Kashmir for the last 50 days (our company’s business from the state has collapsed by a decent percent) after the killing of Wani, I clicked on Madhvi’s article.

    And I’m sharing my thoughts on Kashmir, like I’d have shared if I’d have landed on a Tibetian website or Palestinian website or a Maoist website or if I was alive back then, the freedom struggle website.

    There are human right violations happening in Kashmir, in the name of power and in the name of religion. That’s quite sick. And silly.

    Deliberately expanding the Human out of the Human Rights Violations perspective – a few hundred thousand years ago, all the continents were joined together. A few thousand years ago, religion didn’t exist. A few hundred years ago, many of these recognized nations as on 2016, didn’t exist. State and country boundaries change every 50 to 100 years.

    What will exist in 50 years from now maybe Kashmir as a separate nation, maybe as a part of India, maybe as a part of Pakistan. Maybe all of us will be occupied by another white superpower again. Who knows, really. And a lot of us may live another 50 years to see what happens.

    What did exist all this while were us humans, and our families, and our love for them, and for our community and our fellow beings.

    Human right violations are deplorable everywhere and we all always hope that none of us ever go through what we read about in these “mishap articles” on websites and in social media.

    Let’s all be thankful if we’ve never been subjected to it.

    But then when someone or someone’s family has been, then tempers rise for that person’s life has been destroyed. And I don’t blame that Kashmiri, that Indian, that Pakistani, that Tibetian, that Palestinian or that Nepali whose imminent mission in life becomes revenge – against the wrongdoer.

    And a whole clan of people become endorsers of the tough stand against atrocity. It becomes Us vs The Wrongdoers.

    We label those wrongdoers with groups, names, communities to which we don’t belong – Foreigners, Britishers, Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Pagans, Dalits, Shias, Sunnis, Brahmins, IAS, ISI, BJP, PPP etc.

    And thus we too label ourselves with names, groups, communities or parties – Kashmiris, Tibetians, Palestinians etc.

    And then we hate each other.

    I love Kashmir. I think it has awesome food, especially the Mutton. The phirni is frikking awesome! I think the Dal Lake has gotten dirtier over the years. We must do something to keep it clean. I think Kashmiri men and women are beautiful, with sharp features and clear skin, much like the Iranians!

    I think we should all love Kashmir.

    I think we should all love.

  15. PZ   July 22, 2016 at 8:17 pm

    You deserve an applause for the peice of work… But at the same time I am afraid that only writing things won’t help. You will have to come forth and set an example. Freedom will come but will come at a price and the price shall be paid by all of us. If you have proved yourself capable of writing something good then this gives me hope that people like you can provide us with something that really matters at the ground.

  16. Vijay   July 21, 2016 at 7:20 pm

    Suppose Kashmir got an independent govt, independent constitution and sovereignty and independent what ever, still it does not guarantee that one day when Kashmiris revolt against the govt the troops sent to quell will not do what these so called ‘occupation forces’ do. It is in the dna of the troops to behave the way they do, cause they have a responsibility to restore an order in time that they have no clues on how to it in a human way.

  17. Jamila   July 20, 2016 at 7:57 pm

    Tell me about the mindset of a person who starts to become a Medical Doctor, to serve his community but then Greed for Authority takes over. This person, and others similar to his mind set can’t be trusted.

  18. jameel shaheen   July 19, 2016 at 6:54 pm

    A million sacrifices would not gain that positive recognition and respect for the people of Jammu & Kashmir which Dr. Shah Faisal achieved by topping the Competition. The ‘write up’ is part of a well-calculated campaign, as everybody in the country is not happy by this trend and confidence of the local youth. “chalaow rasm ki koi na sar uthaa ke caley” is the motive behind this campaign.

  19. A human being   July 16, 2016 at 11:42 am

    Mere bhai, you believe it or not, you are first Indian and then Kashmiri.!

    Try to understand the history and be rational in your thoughts, it’s politicians that makes you feel that you are not a part of India, but if you check the history this whole nation was one. It’s not going to make any difference to any politicians weather some kids dies or takes guns, at the end of the day. They will sit in their safe haven and ask common man to come to street, and when time comes they will be sitting in the chair, ruling poor and deprived ones.

    So try to understand this path has noting to gain, instead please join the main stream of the nation, give your family and loved ones a descent life, after all everybody has to die either Allah ka bunda ya fir Ram ka Bhakt.

    You are here on this earth for the cause of humanity and not the cause of militancy. All causes preached to you are not Allah’s cause, are the causes of so called Akkas (Politicians).

    May god, allah, ram, rahim bring peace and prosperity to Kashmir and entire world.


  20. kk   June 22, 2016 at 4:48 pm

    the writer is a failed person in life.

  21. Vakil   June 14, 2016 at 1:15 pm

    If these authors have any guts, they should carry out their ‘Kashmiri version of Nuremberg’ against Shah Faesal — to make an example of him! No doubt they will take the cue from the likes of Baghdadi etc … but do they have any guts, or are they just wearing bangles? Armchair/social-media warriors like these are precisely why the Kashmiri ‘freedom struggle’ has become a raging joke the world over.

  22. Hikmat yar   June 1, 2016 at 6:13 pm

    food is neither given by India nor Pakistan ;;;it is ALLAH who provides us all that we need;;try to understand”

  23. Raoof Iqbal   May 16, 2016 at 11:43 am

    A masterpiece indeed by d trio. But d whole situation described applies in a case when kashmiris as a whole accept india as an occupier but what I see today is that overwhelming majority has surrendered mainly cz of directionless n visionless leaders n desisting of intelligentsia of kashmir to lead instead of writing pieces in cozy rooms enjoyin branded products of occupiers n last to say d hypocrisy on my part too b4 blaming others.

  24. nitasha   May 16, 2016 at 5:57 am

    I smell something burning. Green with envy han?

  25. Sajad Malik   May 15, 2016 at 7:14 pm

    Udayan Sharma,
    Your “condemnation” of rapes in Kashmir are noted and a Kashmiri feels on cloud nine to hear about your condemnation..I think we should celeberate your “condemnation” but then why should we? Did I hear you say, “but then these incidents happen in other parts of country”. So effectively you approve of rape by Indian occupational forces and with a wry on your face, you derive a sadistic pleasure that your media never feeds you such stories and you have an audacity to compare it with “other parts of country” as if Kashmir was India! This is arrogance, plain and simple.

  26. RAK   May 15, 2016 at 4:55 pm

    The authors of this piece of the article should write about the police force which constitutes about 37% (Reportedly) Kashmiri people who are the point of contention > Without their “collaboration” India could hardly have dreamed illegal occupation of this part of Kashmir > In suppressing any legitimate voice of freedom from an illegal rule, it is police force only who play against their own people & add to their miseries, ……………………………………………….

  27. Taha   May 15, 2016 at 1:07 pm

    LOL. A desperate attempt to justify jealousy and incompetence by a bunch of neo-hipster-pseudo-intellectual-conspiracy-theorist “freedom fighters”. 😀

  28. Aamir Parray   May 14, 2016 at 10:30 pm

    it’s a biased one …therez other side of coin too ….u hv deliberately avoided pros … how can ‘revolutionaries’ go gaga like this unless they want blood revolution …inculcate acceptance within u

  29. Burooj   May 14, 2016 at 12:30 pm

    Puts the IAS in some historical perspective. And of course covers some very unsavoury and ugly sides of this job. Notwithstanding a strong writeup, it demonises en mass. I can replace IAS with a chief engineer or a VC or a cricket player, and can easily paint a diabolic picture by refering to the worst examples in each occupation. There is a variegated spectrum of people who engage with the authority their job provides them differently. While some are unabashedly bad, many others are not.

  30. Anonymous   May 14, 2016 at 11:50 am

    Qualifying IAS by a Kashmiri is not just another inconsequential competitive feat, as some people portray it, but something of immense positive possibilities. Personally, I have never been attracted to civil services, or a government job, and never applied for anything like that. But it is unwise to blanketly reject greater Kashmiri embrace of IAS as akin to “collaboration.” Whether we like it or not, IAS civil servants take most of the key decisions that influence people’s lives in profound ways. True the system is beset with immense imperfections, but Kashmiri youngsters must do a cool-headed analysis to learn how worse things could be if there are no natives in civil services in Kashmir. They must sit with some seniors of integrity to understand how everyday work at such levels could be a form of resistance in itself. They must also learn about the immense good they could do to make their people’s lives better, safer. — Arjimand H. T.

  31. Ahmad   May 14, 2016 at 11:33 am

    By your logic, all government employees should resign. And then after, where shall they beg for food? Pakistan?

  32. Aniket   May 14, 2016 at 11:13 am

    Long live dissent,

  33. Udayan Sharma   May 14, 2016 at 10:20 am

    I can easily understand the frustration of the 3 authors either because they are well below the eligibility requirement or lack the necessary guts to crack this examination. The only second case could be the lack of understanding for IAS or other UPSC services altogether. My friend , these services are not just a bunch of people doing paperwork but are the backbone of this country. The IAS in perticular works in tandem with the state and central machinery And is the head of the district executive. I fully condemn the atrocities and rapes in the Kashmir valley and would never defend those unfortunate instances. But these instances happen in various parts of the country too. we have a lot to improve in our delivery system whether it’s justice or policy systems to reach to the bottom level. I think civil services have rightfully gained the deserving status in our society because it’s the only way you can improve the system from inside and do something substantially while making and implementing public policy. Like shah Faisal,IAS 2009 has made us all proud laying the path for all of us and his records show he has actually moved things in his postings, actually improved public policy initiatives with transparency and accountability in Kashmir, made representation of Kashmir in favour of Kashmir and Kashmiri people in the corridors of powers in Delhi. He is just not speaking or writing like us, but improving the situation in the ground level actually! Students long for this power. Power to do something substantial. Power to be able to improve things. Power to have a say in the worlds largest democracy. Power to represent the country internationally.Power to compete and improve themselves in the worlds toughest exam where selection chances are 0.0001 percent. The Power to protect their loved ones and the social recognition is something that comes automatically. While I truly condemn the things that happened in Kashmir, I think the only way forward is to integrate the people of Kashmir with the rest of India. Can Kashmir become independent peacefully? Can we risk our loved ones lives in the process continuing our disregard to the Indian state which offers great opportunities economically , culturally and all that’s needed for our peaceful lives ? Is it too much to ask for ? Cant we integrate ourselves with a rising superpower ? Can’t we just channelise our intellect in the right direction?Can’t we learn from the past where enough blood has already spilled? How long have we been doing this ? Is it working ? Are external state and non state actors really helping us ? Don’t they rape or take our women along ? Or else why do they just drop bombs and in response force Indian military to grow presence in retaliation and then they inspect everyhome and then give motive to some instances like alleged rapes and further atrocities. I am not justifying anything and I cannot. But I think we need to introspect and move on in the right direction

  34. Zubair Khan   May 14, 2016 at 9:45 am

    Excellent work the triad, waiting for Faysal’s to lay the final nail in decimating this BS around IAS bollocks

  35. S.B.   May 14, 2016 at 7:45 am

    The piece is good, though not better. There is no clue to the solution of this disputed land by Ur greatness but wt I find, is only confrontation to that what U might to dream. It was Ghandhi who converged the diversified movement at early 1920’s. I think U may choose the same.