‘Hawkish’ Army chief , Antony scuttled Siachen initiative: Manmohan’s ex-aide

NEW DELHI: Indian Prime Manmohan Singh’s peace initiative for Siachen, the world’s highest and coldest battlefield, was effectively torpedoed by the “hawkish” position of defence minister AK Antony, as also his predecessor Pranab Mukherjee, as well as the then Army chief General JJ Singh.
“I was never sure whether Antony’s hawkish stance was because he genuinely disagreed with the Siachen initiative or whether he was merely toeing a Nehru-Gandhi family line that would not allow Dr Singh to be the one finally normalizing relations with Pakistan. After all, the Kashmir problem had its roots in Nehru’s policies … I felt Sonia would want to wait till Rahul became PM so that he could claim credit,” Singh’s media adviser during UPA-I, Sanjaya Baru, has claimed in his new book “The Accidental Prime Minister”.
Both Mukerjee and Antony, as successive defence ministers in UPA-I, were not enthusiastic about a deal on Siachen, though Sonia had “blessed”” the peace formula. Moreover, the PM also had to contend with “a declining quality” in military leadership. “In closed-door briefings, the general would say that a deal with Pakistan was doable, but in public he would back Antony when the defence minister chose not to back the PM,” says Baru.
Gen Singh, who was the Army chief from 2005 to 2007 and Arunachal Pradesh governor till last year, hit back on Saturday. “What does he (Baru) know? What are his qualifications to pass such sweeping judgements and make disparaging statements on the military leadership? Does he have any idea what leadership is all about?” said Gen Singh .
Dismissing Baru’s knowledge of classified matters, Gen Singh said the military had given “perfectly sound advice” to the PM on the Siachen imbroglio. “We said unless Pakistan authenticates the troop positions, both on the ground and maps, there was no question of any withdrawal,” the former Army chief said.
And even if Pakistan agreed to this pre-condition, the disengagement and demilitarization of the Siachen could only be done in a phased manner. “If Pakistan tried to indulge in some misadventure (to take the heights), the response and reaction time of our troops would have to be factored in. I am happy India’s continues with the same stand,” said Gen Singh.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.